FANDOM


Who would win? Here's what I think would occur. I'm not going to include Taryn because she quit or Maxfield because he was eliminated in the first round (sorry). Please post your opinions, too!


Top 12: Contender's Choice

  1. Abraham - This Love by Maroon 5.
  2. Ali - What I Did For Love from A Chorus Line.
  3. Aylin - California King Bed by Rihanna.
  4. Blake - I Don't Wanna Be by Gavin DeGraw.
  5. Charlie - Something's Coming from West Side Story.
  6. Dani - Ironic by Alanis Morisette.
  7. Lily Mae - Set Fire To The Rain by Adele.
  8. Mario - I Feel Good by James Brown.
  9. Michael - My Way by Frank Sinatra.
  10. Nellie - The Cave by Mumford & Sons.
  11. Shanna - Beautiful by Christina Aguilera.
  12. Tyler - Your Song by Elton John.
  • ​Bottom Three: Tyler, Michael, and Dani.
  • Eliminated: Tyler Ford.

Top 11: Billboard Number One Hits

  1. Shanna - Bleeding Love by Leona Lewis, 2008.
  2. Charlie - The House Of The Rising Sun by The Animals, 1964.
  3. Michael - Sittin' On The Dock Of The Bay by Otis Redding, 1968.
  4. Blake - Kiss From A Rose by Seal, 1995.
  5. Dani - Take My Breath Away by Berlin, 1986.
  6. Mario - I Want You Back by The Jackson 5, 1970.
  7. Abraham - Eye Of The Tiger by Survivor, 1982.
  8. Lily Mae - Black Velvet by Alannah Myles, 1990.
  9. Nellie - How Deep Is Your Love by The Bee Gee's, 1978.
  10. Ali - Firework by Katy Perry, 2010.
  11. Aylin - My Heart Will Go On by Celine Dion, 1998.
  • ​Bottom Three: Michael, Mario, and Nellie.
  • Eliminated: Mario Bonds.

Top 10: British Invasion

  1. Lily Mae - Love Potion #9 by The Searchers.
  2. Ali - Hey Jude by The Beatles.
  3. Blake - Wild Thing by The Troggs.
  4. Michael - My Generation by The Who.
  5. Nellie - Time Of The Season by The Zombies.
  6. Aylin - Satisfaction by The Rolling Stones.
  7. Shanna - I Want To Hold Your Hand by The Beatles.
  8. Charlie - To Sir With Love by Lulu.
  9. Abraham - She's Not There by The Zombies.
  10. Dani - Gimme Some Lovin' by The Spencer Davis Group.
  • 'Bottom Three': Dani, Abraham, and Ali.
  • Eliminated: Dani Shay.

Top 9: Queen

  1. Blake - We Are The Champions by Queen.
  2. Nellie - Save Me by Queen.
  3. Lily Mae - Somebody To Love by Queen.
  4. Ali - Spread Your Wings by Queen.
  5. Michael - We Will Rock You by Queen.
  6. Shanna - The Show Must Go On by Queen.
  7. Charlie - Fat Bottomed Girls by Queen.
  8. Aylin - Bohemian Rhapsody by Queen.
  9. Abraham - Don't Stop Me Now by Queen.
  • ​Bottom Three: Abraham, Aylin, and Ali.
  • Eliminated: Abraham Lim.

Top 8: Country

  1. Aylin - Before He Cheats by Carrie Underwood.
  2. Charlie - What Hurts The Most by Rascal Flatts.
  3. Shanna & Lily Mae - Stay by Sugarland.
  4. Blake - Love Like Crazy by Lee Brice.
  5. Nellie - Redneck Woman by Gretchen Wilson.
  6. Aylin & Ali - Mean by Taylor Swift.
  7. Shanna - Springsteen by Eric Church.
  8. Michael - Tomorrow by Chris Young.
  9. Nellie & Charlie - Need You Now by Lady Antebellum.
  10. Ali - Good Girl by Carrie Underwood.
  11. Lily Mae - White Horse by Taylor Swift.
  12. Michael & Blake - God Gave Me You by Blake Shelton.
  • ​Bottom Three: Blake, Nellie, and Lily Mae.
  • Eliminated: Lily Mae Harrington.

Top 7: American Classics

  1. Nellie - What A Wonderful World by Louie Armstrong.
  2. Ali - Smile by Charlie Chaplin.
  3. Michael - It Had To Be You by Sam Lanin & his Orchestra.
  4. Shanna - Mack The Knife by Louie Armstrong.
  5. Aylin - Don't Get Around Much Anymore by Duke Ellington.
  6. Blake - For Once In My Life by Ron Miller.
  7. Charlie - I Get A Kick Out Of You by Frank Sinatra.
  • ​Bottom Three: Charlie, Blake, and Shanna.
  • Eliminated: Charlie Lubeck.

Top 6: Broadway

  1. Aylin - Whispering from Spring Awakening.
  2. Nellie - Somewhere from West Side Story.
  3. Blake & Nellie - As Long As You're Mine from Wicked.
  4. Michael - Sandy from Grease.
  5. Shanna - Memory from Cats.
  6. Ali & Michael - Without You from RENT.
  7. Blake - Giants In The Sky from Into The Woods.
  8. Ali - Think Of Me from The Phantom Of The Opera.
  9. Shanna & Aylin - Everything's Coming Up Rose from Gypsy.
  • Bottom Three: Aylin, Nellie, and Blake.
  • Eliminated: Blake Jenner.

Top 5: Inspirational Songs/Party Songs

  1. Shanna - Dream On by Aerosmith.
  2. Michael - You've Got A Friend by Carole King.
  3. Nellie - Imagine by John Lennon.
  4. Ali - Over The Rainbow by Judy Garland.
  5. Aylin - Anyway by Martina McBride.
  6. Shanna - Dynamite by Taio Cruz.
  7. Michael - I Gotta Feeling by The Black Eyed Peas.
  8. Nellie - We Are Family by Sister Sledge.
  9. Ali - Party Rock Anthem by LMFAO.
  10. Aylin - On The Floor by Pitbull ft. Jennifer Lopez.
  • ​Bottom Three: Shanna, Michael, and Ali.
  • Eliminated: Ali Stroker.

Top 4: Michael Jackson/Disco

  1. Nellie - Billie Jean by Michael Jackson.
  2. Aylin - Human Nature by Michael Jackson.
  3. Shanna & Nellie - Black Or White by Michael Jackson.
  4. Shanna - Rock With You by Michael Jackson.
  5. Michael - Man In The Mirror by Michael Jackson.
  6. Nellie - Funky Town by Lipps Inc.
  7. Aylin - I Will Survive by Gloria Gaynor.
  8. Aylin & Michael - Last Dance by Donna Summer.
  9. Shanna - Disco Inferno by The Trammps.
  10. Michael - Turn The Beat Around by Gloria Estefan,
  • ​Bottom Three: Aylin, Shanna, and Nellie.
  • Eliminated: Shanna Henderson.

Top 3: The Beatles/Broadway/Contender's Choice

  1. Nellie - Eleanor Rigby by The Beatles.
  2. Michael - Strawberry Fields Forever by The Beatles.
  3. Aylin - All My Loving by The Beatles.
  4. Nellie - All That Jazz from Chicago.
  5. Michael - Luck Be A Lady from Guys & Dolls.
  6. Aylin - Defying Gravity from Wicked.
  7. Michael, Aylin, & Nellie - We Are Young by fun.
  8. Nellie - You Oughta Know by Alanis Morisette.
  9. Michael - Fly Me To The Moon by Frank Sinatra.
  10. Aylin - Without You by David Guetta ft. Usher.
  • Eliminated: Michael Weisman.

Top 2: Contender's Choices

  1. Aylin - Take A Bow by Rihanna.
  2. Nellie - White Blank Page by Mumford & Sons.
  3. Aylin - Like A Prayer by Madonna.
  4. Nellie - Titanium by David Guetta ft. Sia.
  5. Aylin & Nellie - Everyday by Britney Spears.
  6. Aylin - On My Own from Les Miserables.
  7. Nellie - Fix You by Coldplay.
  • ​Eliminated: Aylin Bayramoglu.
  • Winner: Nellie Veitenheimer.

Ad blocker interference detected!


Wikia is a free-to-use site that makes money from advertising. We have a modified experience for viewers using ad blockers

Wikia is not accessible if you’ve made further modifications. Remove the custom ad blocker rule(s) and the page will load as expected.